Showing posts with label Star Trek. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Star Trek. Show all posts

Wednesday, August 8, 2012

Review: Star Trek / Legion of Super-Heroes hardcover

Good crossovers are few and far between but, as a huge fan of both Star Trek movies and Legion of Super-Heroes comics (from the Mark Waid days on), I was excited to pick up the first issue to try it out. Luckily I was able to snag the last one on the rack. As each issue was released, it got harder to get a copy unless I was there the day it came out. It was popular and after reading the hardcover, I can see why.

When Kirk, Spock, McCoy, Sulu, Chekov, and Uhura board a transporter pad bound for shore leave and Cosmic Boy, Saturn Girl, Lightning Lad, Chameleon Boy, Shadow Lass, and Brainiac 5 escape the time stream, both groups end up in an alternate universe. It seems both universes have merged. The alien races from the Legion of Super-Heroes are present as well as a twisted version of the Federation of Planets. The two teams track a chronal aberration - each other - and quickly decide that they should team up to figure out how to restore their time streams.

The story is fantastic and each team is very well handled by Roberson while Moy and Jimenez do a great job with likenesses, action, and the two page spread showing all the various 'time machines' the villain has confiscated will make the most hardcore fan faint. I can't say enough good stuff about this mini series as it seemed effortlessly well told and was fun and action packed and had a satisfying end.

Sunday, April 22, 2012

Star Trek vs Star Wars: Round Four

Back in my February 18th post I explained how I wanted to compare the first six Star Wars and Star Trek movies to see how I felt about them after all these years of not seeing them. You can see the first three rounds here: Round One, Round Two, and Round Three. 

Before I get into the review, I can’t express enough how much Star Wars: A New Hope, meant to me as a kid. I had the toys and enjoyed playing with my friends. Back when the movie came out there was no such things as blu ray or Netflix. I don’t think I saw the movie again until after Return of the Jedi came out – it was on TV one night and my parents let me stay up late to watch it.

When it came out on VHS I picked up the trilogy and watched them again and again. Then the movies were turned into ‘Special Editions’ and I rewatched them in all their digitally remastered glory on the big screen.

But since then I haven’t watched the movies. I upgraded from VHS to DVD and the I never watched them. Then the blu ray came out and I promised myself that I would watch them again.

Then I decided on the Star Trek vs Star Wars challenge.

ROUND THREE: Star Trek IV: The Voyage Home vs Star Wars Episode IV: A New Hope

Star Trek IV: The Voyage Home
Kirk and company have stolen Federation property, destroyed that property, and have ignored their orders. Having saved Captain Spock, the crew is prepared to return to Earth and face the consequences. But an energy probe is threatening the Earth and the crew has to take the HMS Bounty (their captured Klingon Bird of Prey) back through time to capture a pair of humpback whales and bring them back to the future.

This final chapter of a trilogy that started at The Wrath of Khan isn’t just the funniest film in the Star Trek franchise, it’s also the most fun. The crew breaks up into teams where they all get to have their own adventure while trading fun dialogue, breaking all the rules of time travel (as in not doing anything to alter time…like decloaking in front of a whaling ship, letting the military get a hold of a Klingon phaser, communicator, and Checkov’s Starfleet identification, or giving someone the molecular formula to transparent aluminum). And it’s always fun when someone normal like Gillian gets in on the action and gets to interact with the crew and sit on the bridge.

After all these years I still laugh at the appropriate places and I’m still glued to the film. Although the cars, boombox, and fashion in this film make it look dated, it would have been a great film no matter when it was filmed. Kirk and his crew have never been as fun or as likeable as they are here.
Star Wars Episode IV: A New Hope
Luke Skywalker is a young man on Tatooine who dreams of adventure. He gets more than he bargained for when the only family he knows is murdered and he takes on Stormtroopers, a trash compactor, and destroys a planet-sized space station.

This movie would have been fantastic as a stand-alone movie but is the first part of an amazing trilogy. It does a great job setting up the Star Wars mythology while providing great introductions to the main characters.

As I’m re-watching the film I’m taken by how much it still means to me and to all the fans. Star Wars gave us a lot of new heroes to root for and took us on the adventure of a lifetime. And it hits me that while I could point out all of the digitally changed scenes, I find that everything blends in and compliments the movie (except for Greedo shooting first and the ‘stuttering’ motion as Han walks over Jabba’s tail (in the original deleted scene, Jabba was played by a human being so walking behind that person makes more sense)) so I don’t mind any of the ‘improvements’ to the movie.

And I did pick up one thing I don’t know if I’ve ever noticed. There’s a scene where C-3P0 tells Luke that he’s not very good at telling stories – and then I think about him telling the Ewoks an engaging story complete with sound effects.

AND ROUND FOUR GOES TO STAR TREK IV: THE VOYAGE HOME

While Star Wars might be an important beginning and a movie I love dearly, there are a few scenes where Tarkin and Vader talk about the senate and when discussing how the senate will react to Princess Leia being taken, Vader tells someone to send out a distress signal and say all aboard Leia’s ship was killed (like a cover up). The prequels say being a Jedi takes years and considering how Anakin turned evil, Obi-Wan is quick to rush Luke, clearly too old for training with no control over his emotions, into a little light training before deciding he’d be better off guiding Luke as a spirit (I don’t know how that makes someone more powerful if all Jedi can hang out and give advice as spirits).

And Luke takes to everything with success (I know – the force is strong with him) from shooting Stormtroopers (which he does without regret for the people he’s killing even though he’s never killed anyone before), working the Falcon’s laser turret, and flying an X-Wing.

The Voyage Home was easily the best Star Trek film and it gave me more laughs and adventure. I don’t have definitive proof that one is better than the other – it’s an indefensible position. A New Hope is clearly more popular but as a fan of both, I’d rather watch The Voyage Home again.

Tally:
Star Trek: 2
Star Wars: 2

Sunday, March 25, 2012

Star Trek vs Star Wars: Round Two


Back in my February 18th post I explained how I wanted to compare the first six Star Wars and Star Trek movies. You can see that blog here.

ROUND TWO: Star Trek II: The Wrath of Khan vs Star Wars Episode II: Attack of the Clones

Star Trek II: The Wrath of Khan
Again, Admiral Kirk finds himself taking control of the Enterprise to do the one thing he was born to do: command a starship. When Khan takes control of his own Federation starship, it leads the crew of the Enterprise to the edge of survival, unites James T. Kirk with the son he never knew, and leads to the death of Captain Spock.

When I was a kid, I remember liking this movie and being terrified by the bug that crawls into Chekov’s ear. I must have watched this film a dozen times on VHS. I was such a huge fan.

After all these years, there were things I forgot about in the plot. I forgot about Chekov’s ‘betrayal,’ Khan detonating the Genesis device (I thought he just activated the self-destruct), and a lot of small stuff.

In watching it again, I found myself just as big a fan as I’ve ever been. Khan’s motivation and ability easily makes him the most imposing villain to go up against the Enterprise’s crew. At the beginning of the movie the Enterprise is being taken out on a training voyage with a load of cadets who scatter as soon as the first attack begins.

The movie is terrific for many reasons: 1) it shows a really fierce starship battle in which neither side seems to have any clear advantage through most of the film, 2) there is a lot of fantastic dialogue between the characters, and 3) the moving death of Spock.

All of these years later and I still get excited when the Enterprise rises up behind the Reliant in the Nebula and lays waste to her. Although I still wish we’d gotten to see Khan’s expression when Enterprise went to warp speed.



Star Wars Episode II: Attack of the Clones
Ten years after the events in the Phantom Menace, Senator Palpatine convinces the Jedi Council to assign Senator Amidala Jedi protection. When the council assigns Obi-Wan Kenobi and his Padawan, Anakin Skywalker, the reunion sparks something in Padme and Anakin that results in them marrying in secret. Meanwhile Obi-Wan uncovers a large clone army and inadvertently begins a war – just as Senator Palpatine had planned all along.

When I saw this film opening weekend, I guess I was still suffering from the open wound of The Phantom Menace because I hated this movie. I thought Anakin and Padme’s many scenes together so close together where they’re hanging out and bonding was a little much back then. I also couldn’t follow Obi-Wan’s story because I didn’t really understand the politics of everything. I also think I was impatient and wanted to answers faster than I was getting them. And it irritated me that Anakin whined more than Luke did in A New Hope.

When I watched this movie again, I found that most of the things I didn’t like had disappeared. I found all the scenes with Anakin and Padame bonding were actually enjoyable. I still didn’t like the lack of emotion between the two – especially when Anakin tells Padme that he senses his mother is suffering and tells her he has to go and Padme says nothing. I wanted her to be the one to say – ‘then we have to go’ like she does when they go off to save Obi-Wan at the end.

Overall, I enjoyed watching this film a lot more than I thought I would.


AND ROUND TWO GOES TO STAR TREK II: THE WRATH OF KHAN

While Attack of the Clones was a good, fun movie, but there was no real worry that the main characters were in any real danger (except Padme with the worm creatures). And I find it hard to believe that Darth Vader couldn’t find Luke hiding in plain sight on Tatooine with his step-brother. It’s also hard to imagine C-3P0 not telling Luke that he was created by another Skywalker.

The Wrath of Khan had these two passionate leaders who hated each other. All through the movie, Kirk and Khan traded starship fire and heated words. And the picture started on sort of a negative note (with all the "I'm getting older" talk) and had a hopeful ending. The dialogue was great, the action was terrific, it was clearly superior to Attack of the Clones.

While I can see myself watching Attack of the Clones again, it’s easier to imagine me watching Wrath of Khan a lot more.


Tally:
Star Trek: 1
Star Wars: 1

Saturday, February 18, 2012

Star Trek vs Star Wars: Round One

A few months back William Shatner and Carrie Fisher’s Star Trek vs Star Wars debate was big genre news. Of course it was all tongue-in-cheek between the two of them. On Sept 15, 2011, William Shatner said, "Star Wars is derivative” and Carrie fired back on Nov 10, 2011 with a three minute video making fun of Star Trek and William Shatner. Then Shatner fired back on Nov 28, 2011 with a funny video responding to Carrie Fisher’s video.

All of the Star Trek vs Star Wars stuff from Shatner and Fisher were really funny and aren’t unlike the debates that genre fans have had for years. I have the feeling that most of us sci-fi nerds love both franchises.

As a kid, I saw Star Wars with my Grandma – I was 4 years old and fell in love with the characters and the story. The rest the movies, including the prequels, I saw with my dad – it was our tradition. My dad and I also had another tradition – seeing the Star Trek movies together.

While I loved Star Wars from the beginning, I didn’t immediately take to Star Trek. As a kid, I thought the original series was creepy, full of aliens who were always holding Kirk captive or fighting him to the death. And I fell asleep during the first Star Trek film both times my dad took me to see it. Then came Wrath of Khan and I never looked back.

I loved the first three Star Wars films and disliked the three prequels. And of the six Star Trek films that featured the original cast, I only loved the even numbered movies (2, 4, and 6) and disliked the other films. This means that of the two franchises, I liked half the films and disliked the other half.

When it was announced that Lucas was re-releasing the movies, in order, in 3D, I thought it would be a great time to re-explore my love of the franchise. I haven’t seen any of the Star Wars films or the original six Star Trek movies in about 10 years. I only saw the Star Wars prequels one time when they were on the big screen so I don’t remember a whole lot about them.

So I decided to have my own version of Star Trek vs Star Wars. I am going to re-watch each of the movies in order and compare them, starting with Star Trek: The Motion Picture and Star Wars Episode 1: The Phantom Menace.

I’m excited to see how I still feel about these films all these years later. Will I still only like half the films of each franchise or will I appreciate them more seeing them again? I only saw the Star Wars Prequels once – did I give them a fair chance or hate them because of my own unrealistic expectations of the franchise?

So, without further ado, here is Star Trek The Motion Picture vs Star Wars Episode I: The Phantom Menace:

ROUND ONE: Star Trek The Motion Picture vs Star Wars Episode I: The Phantom Menace

Star Trek The Motion Picture

Ten years after the five-year voyage was canceled, the original crew reunited to the delight of old fans and the new fans who were introduced to the series via reruns. When I was little, my Dad took me to see this film twice and I fell asleep both times. I think I saw this film again when it came out on VHS but it’s been at least 20 years since I sat down and watched this film.

Overall, I can see why I fell asleep in the theatre as a kid. The movie crawls along at a snails pace with a lot of pointless dialogue and endless shots of the ship leaving space dock and slowly exploring V’ger.

There are some nice moments between the crew members but there wasn’t enough warmth in the initial meeting between Kirk and his crew when he first appears on the bridge like there was with Scotty on the shuttle ride over. I also found McCoy’s oddly stuffed into the crew as the guy who is drafted by Kirk to face certain doom (“Bones, I need you.” For what? There’s already a doctor on board and the mission is going to be less than a week long.). Then there’s the super-cold entrance of Spock and the strange way everyone stares at him like the way he’s acting is weird – they know him and his behavior shouldn’t be shocking.

Except for Kirk, Spock, and McCoy, the rest of the characters are ignored while the trio reconnects awkwardly. I like the other members of the crew and was disappointed that they didn’t get more of a chance to do anything.

Star Wars Episode I: The Phantom Menace

When Jedi and his Padawan are dispatched to deal with a Federation blockade of the planet Naboo they uncover an invasion plot, a little boy strong in the force, and a Sith. New characters are introduced while old friends like Obi-Wan Kenobi, Yoda, R2-D2, and C-3P0 are along for the ride.

Unlike the original trilogy, all of the aliens speak with accents you can find on Earth. The Gungans, and most of the aliens in the movie, remind me of Disney characters and it’s hard to take the Gungans seriously with their silly dialogue and demeanor. Jar Jar Binks is unwatchable as a clumsy goof who doesn’t supply laughs. Anakin is ‘born of the force’ as he is immaculately conceived. And we’re introduced to midichlorians which serves to demystify the Force.

When asked what midichlorians are, Qui-Gon explains, “Midi-chlorians are a microscopic life form that resides within all living cells.” In Empire Strikes back, Yoda tells Luke about the Force, “Life creates it, makes it grow. Its energy surrounds us and binds us.”

There’s even a scene where Anakin accidentally destroys a droid control ship, rescuing an army of defeated Gungans.

The story is really weak and some of it serves to destroy things that Star Wars fans hold dear (like demystifying the Force). 

Oh, and then there’s the little matter of taking Anakin, an untrained kid, into a war zone where they instruct him to find a place to hide instead of leaving him on Coruscant where his safety was guaranteed. Apparently there isn’t any Child Protective Services on Coruscant or Naboo. NOTE TO PARENTS: Don’t let the Jedi babysit…ever.
 
ROUND ONE GOES TO STAR WARS EPISODE I: THE PHANTOM MENACE


While Star Wars Episode I: The Phantom Menace still makes me cringe, sitting through Star Trek The Motion Picture was excruciatingly boring. The Phantom Menace had great special effects, big battle scenes, and a great lightsaber duel. And I liked how Queen Amidala had decoys which allowed her to get into the thick of things, disguised as a handmaiden called Padme.

Still, when Qui-Gon could only get Anakin free of slavery but not his mother, I thought Captain Kirk would have freed both, ended slavery on Tatooine, and nailed the mother before the credits rolled.

I can’t imagine loving The Phantom Menace but I can’t imagine falling asleep during it either, so The Phantom Menace wins this round.